« Back to blog

Cholera in Haiti and Injustice for Aid Workers

Many of you read my last post: http://tedfellows.posterous.com/cholera-in-haiti-and-regional-infrastructure Where I spoke of an urgent need for Cholera treatment supplies in Borgne.

The team that actually got those supplies out to Borgne for PAHO was MMRC. A group I have felt does great work and that saves lives. You can see video of this trip to Borgne at their site: http://mmrcglobal.org/cholera-borgne-haiti

Well December 16th the co-founder of MMRC Paul Waggoner is being sent to the Haitian National Penitentiary in Port Au Prince for 3 MONTHS to await the Magistrative Investigation. Like 90% of prisoners at the prison who have never been convicted, he is not convicted, but this is a very dangerous place for him. This is a case that will send a chill through the international aid community. Paul is being accused of stealing a baby by a bereaved father, whose baby died in a hospital in Petionville.

From the MMRC official statement (  http://mmrcglobal.org/first-official-statement  ):

"The child in question died at HCH (Haitian Community Hospital in Petionville) late February while Paul was working logistics at the location. Paul does not work on medical care. The grieving father has stated that he believes Paul stole the baby and that the baby is still alive due to the fact that the baby’s eyes would not close after death. He has reported that Paul either wanted to adopt, or sell the baby."

Paul was a logistical volunteer, taking names, getting supplies, moving paper and goods. He did not provide medical care on the child that died in that hospital, but he is being held responsible for the death of that child by a bereaved father. But this is not only about Paul. This is a situation that provides a a chilling precedent for ALL medical volunteers in Haiti during this fight with Cholera. Who from the international community wants to come to fight Cholera if they fear they can go to jail if they are unable to save somebody?

In the US call your senators, call the State Department at 202-647-4956 and ask for Suzanne Grantham. Also call Overseas Citizens Services at 202-647-5225 and make sure the embassy keeps this situation on the front burner.

But more importantly for Haitians and Haitian diaspora call your senators in Haiti, call your mayors, and let them know this will hit at the heart of all cholera treatment efforts. Ask them to appeal to the judiciary to move forward Paul's processing and find a quick resolution to his case.

I can only hope that Paul is out soon, back to work moving Cholera treatment supplies, and that his accuser is able to receive support and counseling for the loss of his child.

Posted by Peter Haas 

Comments (8)

Dec 16, 2010
Peter Haas said...
http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2010/12/16/nantucket_...

The Boston Globe article on Paul. Note Talk Radio in Haiti has been using Paul as a scapegoat for frustrations with international aid, it is vital that calls for a speedy processing of his case come from within Haiti.

Dec 16, 2010
Peter Haas said...
It is also important to keep in mind the case of Daniel Pye who was also jailed in Haiti with no charges because of a personal grievance.

http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-512087?ref=feeds%2Flatest

Dec 16, 2010
Keep the prayers and phone calls coming. God Bless each person who has joined in this effort.
Dec 16, 2010
I respectfully suggest that Foreign Aid Workers and or groups groups contact [their] senators and congressmen to put some pressure on the Haitian government to immediately issue an Executive Order to provide guidelines and "habeas corpus" rights for Aid Workers and specifically Foreign Aid Workers." If it is the US and foreign countries that finance the Haitian government, they can definitely request an Order either from the Haitian executive of legislature and immediately. Clearly the Haitian government has no choice but to provide this protection for the people who set aside family and work to come provide something they cannot provide.
Dec 16, 2010
Mary Rutten said...
I am so sorry to hear of this situation for Paul and his family and Daniel Pye and his family. As a person who has gone to Haiti since 2002 and who went through a 4 year adoption that dealt with a govt. that changed the rules at the drop of a hat and had few to no legels records what is going on does not suprise me. Many Haitians have no idea that the work that is done there is done by volounteers, people who do not get paid. When I explained this one time they could not believe it. Why would I do such a thing? The government of Haiti is corrupt and backward and really does not care for the people. The govt. can throw Americans in jail who are there to help with no charges or convictions or real proof but they cannot take care of getting their own country on it's feet. If the show were on the other foot and we through a couple of Haitians in jail with no charges, convictions or proof of wrong doing the international community would be up in arms as would ever Haitian. So it is a sad case that this is going on and I have no doubt how dangerous the situation is for Paul and Daniel but at the rate the Haitian govt. works (which is all but non exsistant at present), the way they talk out of both sides of their mouths and say one thing one day and something different the next I can bet that these two will be in jail along time
Dec 16, 2010
Peter Haas said...
It should be noted that Paul has a criminal record where he was convicted of beating up a convicted pedophile and various petty crime. This however I do not believe came into consideration in his Haiti case.
Dec 16, 2010
Peter Haas said...
Much more detailed reporting on Paul's case by Emily Troutman:

http://www.aolnews.com/2010/12/16/us-worker-held-in-haiti-jail-says-hes-being...

and Jon Katz:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/16/AR20101216050...

Emily's post gives a good look explaining Paul's priors in MA.

Mar 22, 2012
ralph eggleston said...
Many Haitians have no idea that the work that is done there is done by volounteers, people who do not get paid. When I explained this one time they could not believe it. Why would I do such a thing? The government of Haiti is corrupt and backward and really does not care for the people

Leave a comment...